I have been offered Peyton Manning for Aaron Rodgers. On paper it looks like a slam dunk to get Manning on my team, but he's had a tough start and his O-line is terrible. Rodgers has started hot, but he's young and could crash any time. any input is appreciated.

...
manning
you're joking right.
PRESS THE ACCEPT BUTTON NOW

lol thats tough idk for sure answers.yahoo.com/question/index;…

no Peyton Manning will rebound and Rodgers has to play the cowboys d

GO WITH ROGERS! he still has something to prove to the world after taking brett favre's place. so every game he will do his best to prove the world wrong. He wants to show that he is good as brett favre or better( in future years) he has motivation.

Manning is good! dont get me wrong, but he is coming back from injury and NO player is the same after injury, except adrian peterson. but yeah. Go with rogers. Manning doesnt have an O Line anymore.

well yeah in paper it looks great but Manning hasn't looked good in the past 2 games. that surgery has definately taking a toll on him for this season. Rodgers so far has played very good and his team actually looks better than the Colts. I would get A-Rodg.

well Manning didnt have Jeff Saturday his main O line guard. Who is Coming back this week so go for it definatley

Keep Rodgers because Peyton Manning is aging and its showing. Brady and Manning are over.

no. peyton manning's getting old and aaron rodgers is just starting out. keep aaron.

Should I trade Aaron Rodgers for Peyton Manning?